16, Sir William Newton Street
Port Louis, Mauritius
Robust and highly capitalised, local banks were able to withstand the shock at the height of the 2007-08 financial crisis. Today, as they are called upon to participate fully in the economic recovery, their resilience is once again being tested. To mitigate the risks, particularly those related to doubtful loans, they can rely on IFRS 9, to help them manage their risks.
Since 1 January 2018, IFRS 9 has changed the way in which companies must prepare their financial statements. They are now required to switch to an impairment model for credit risk. In this post COVID-19 period where banks are particularly vulnerable, how can IFRS 9 help them to better provision for bad debts, especially for the segment B?
COVID-19 has brought to the table a new set of challenges with negative growth, falling consumption, increasing unemployment and rising inflation among others. Thus, the variables used in the development of financial models are no longer valid because of the new challenges that have emerged and are affecting the banking sector as a whole.
As far as IFRS 9 is concerned, it is primarily focused on the treatment of financial data. The revised IFRS 9 models, in fact, factor in the significant increase in credit risk pushing up the probabilities of default that is being reflected in higher impairment provisions for both Segment A and Segment B.
Can it be said that IFRS 9 is a valuable tool for internal control departments?
Credit risk is one of the most significant risks that a bank faces. IFRS 9 has come up with a new way of assessing the level of risks and the relative provisions that need to be recognised. What can be said is that a high level of expert judgement is invariably required in assessing a credit proposal and determining the appropriate level of credit risk related provisions. IFRS 9, however, requires that we make provisions from the very first day a loan is disbursed. The level of provisions depends on various factors, such as the client, the nature of his/her business, his/her past behaviour, while adopting a forward looking view that again requires the use of expert judgement. The provision level should then be regularly reassessed in line with changes in the operating environment.
How can IFRS 9 contribute to strengthening the stability of the financial system?
IFRS 9 requires financial data modelling. If the models are given a proper framework, and are tested and reviewed regularly, they will undoubtedly contribute to the stability of the financial system. The challenge today is that each bank has its own IFRS 9 model that reflects its unique portfolios which leads to a lack of consistency within the industry. As an example, for two similar exposures towards the same company, two different banks will apply different provision levels and the amounts can sometimes vary considerably. But what we have been seeing, as general rule, is an overall increase in provision levels.
How does IFRS 9 differ from IAS 39?
The main change brought about by IFRS 9 compared to IAS 39 relates to the impairment of financial assets. IFRS 9 requires that forward-looking information be used in calculating the appropriate level of provisions to be carried for an asset. Staging is also a new concept that allows the calculation of expected losses over 12 months and over the entire duration of the loan. Other changes introduced are less significant.
Do you think that financial reporting standards used to be too complex?
Financial Reporting standards are becoming more and more demanding and complex. As readers of Financial Statements are today well-informed and sophisticated, more and more disclosures are required in the annual reports which are used for deeper analysis. As a result, through enhanced reporting, greater transparency is achieved and comparisons become much more meaningful.
The new standard has impacted the financial operations of banks. But with hindsight, don’t you think that this transition was necessary, especially at a time when banks need to be more rigorous on credit risks?
IFRS 9 was brought forward following the bad experience during the 2007/2008 financial crisis, when it was felt that the provisions of IAS 39 did not really reflect the credit risk sitting on banks’ balance sheets. Since the relevance of IAS 39 had become questionable, it was absolutely necessary to move to a new framework. The transition from IAS 39 to IFRS 9 resulted in an overall increase in impairment provisions worldwide, including Mauritius. The increased provision levels provide better cushion for difficult times, which is good for the industry as a whole.
Chief Financial Officer at Bank One
Business Magazine, 19 August 2020
Bank One Disclaimer
Welcome to www.bankone.mu!
Please read the following important information before accessing this Website:
This Website is owned and operated by BANK ONE LIMITED and the use thereof indicate that you accept the Bank’s Terms and Conditions of Use.
If you do not agree to the Terms and Conditions of Use, you should not use the Website.
The Bank may, at its entire discretion, at any time and without notice, modify or update such Terms and Conditions of Use. Such changes shall be effective immediately and you shall be deemed to have accepted same if you continue to use the Website.
Although the Bank endeavours to provide correct information on its Website, it does not give any warranty express or implied as to its accuracy, completeness and reliability.
The Bank does not accept any liability for any errors or omissions of whatsoever nature as regards information, materials, functions and applications contained in its Website or as to any third-party Websites linked to or from its Website.
Terms & Conditions of Use
1) Information available on the Website are allowed to be printed and / or downloaded for personal use only and not for commercial purposes.
You may not reproduce, transmit or store any information contained on the Bank’s Website on any other Website without the Bank’s written permission.
2) The Website is intended to provide general information on the Bank and its products and services.
No information contained on the Website shall constitute or is intended to constitute financial, legal, accounting, investment or other professional advice or services. You are advised to take professional advice from a suitably qualified professional or adviser before taking any decision relating to your finances or business.
3) You acknowledge that information transmitted via the Internet is susceptible to monitoring and interception and you will be bear all risk of using such means. You further acknowledge that any unsolicited information communicated to us via Internet cannot be guaranteed to remain confidential.
4) The Website may contain technical, typographical or other inaccuracies and you are urged to contact us to confirm all information contained on this Website before placing any reliance on it.
5) The Bank agrees to make reasonable efforts to ensure full performance of its Internet Banking transactions. The Bank will be responsible for acting only on those instructions sent through Internet Banking which are actually received. The Bank does not assume responsibility for any malfunctioning in communication facilities not under its control that may affect the accuracy or timeliness of messages you send. The Bank will not be responsible for any losses or delays in transmission of instructions arising or caused by any browser software. It will, furthermore, not be accountable should you provide incorrect instructions or if your payment instructions are not given sufficiently in advance to allow for timely payment or delays in mail service.
Collection of Information
The Bank will not collect any information about you except where it is knowingly provided to us through this Website. The information we collect about you will depend on how you use the facilities offered via this web site.
In the event that you enter information in the process of completion of an online application form, the information will only be collected by us if you submit that online application to us. In other words, if you log out prior to submitting your application, any information which you had entered would be automatically deleted.
The Bank requires information to understand your needs and provide you with a better service, and in particular for the following reasons:
Internal record keeping.
Use the information to improve its products and services.
Sending periodicals and promotional emails on new products, special offers or other information which the Bank thinks you may find interesting using the email address which you have provided.
Our Contact Centre may call you to suggest products and services that are relevant to your needs based on the information you have provided.
Occasionally, the Bank may also use your personal information to contact you for market research purposes.
The Bank may contact you by email, phone, fax or mail and may use the information provided to customise the Website according to your interests.
The Bank will not sell or distribute your personal information to third parties unless it has your permission or is required by law to do so. You may request details of personal information which the Bank holds about you under the Data Protection Act 2004. If you would like a copy of the information held on you, please write to us.
If you believe that any information the Bank is holding on you is incorrect or incomplete, please write to or email us as soon as possible. The Bank will promptly correct any information found to be incorrect.
In no event will the Bank be liable for any damages including but not limited to direct or indirect, special, incidental, consequential or punitive damages, losses or expenses arising out of the use of its Website, or incurred as a result of any failure of performance, transmission of information, any interruption or availability of its Website, delay in operation or transmission, computer virus, loss of data, or otherwise.
Neither the Bank nor its directors, shareholders, agents, consultants, representatives, officers or employees shall be liable for any damages or losses resulting from your use or inability to use its Website or any information contained therein, including without limitation any direct or indirect, special, incidental, consequential or punitive damages whether arising out of contract, statute and tort or otherwise.